How to Grow Tomatoes in Fall: Expert Tips & Frost Protection

So here’s the thing about growing tomatoes into fall – most people wait way too long to start thinking about it, then panic when frost threatens and just yank everything out of the ground. Or they read some vague advice about “protecting plants from cold” and think tossing a bedsheet over them the night before a freeze will save everything.

Spoiler alert: it won’t.

I’ve been growing tomatoes for years now and honestly the first few seasons I screwed up the fall transition pretty badly. One year I had these beautiful plants loaded with green fruit in September, didn’t do anything special, and then boom – frost hit and I lost everything. Another year I tried bringing pots inside too late and dealt with spider mites for months.

But here’s what I’ve figured out after actually reading the research and talking to extension agents who know their stuff: extending your tomato season into fall is totally doable, but it requires planning ahead and understanding some basic plant biology. Not complicated stuff, just knowing what temperatures actually matter and which protection methods work.

The difference between harvesting tomatoes in October versus losing them all in September often comes down to just a few degrees and some simple techniques.

The Temperature Thing Everyone Gets Wrong

Tomatoes don’t just suddenly die at 32°F. There’s actually a whole range of critical temperatures you need to know.

The sweet spot for ripening is 68-77°F. Research from Cornell shows this is where tomatoes ripen fastest with the best color and flavor [1]. When nighttime temperatures hit 55°F and below, tomato pollen becomes sterile [1]. Those late-season blossoms? They won’t set fruit anyway.

The real problem zone starts at 50°F. Extended exposure causes chilling injury, which destroys the enzymes for proper ripening [2]. Your tomatoes might eventually turn red, but they’ll taste bland and mealy. At 32°F you get frost, and unprotected plants die. But between 50°F and 32°F, you’ve got this window where plants are cold-stressed but alive – that’s where frost protection works.

For most of the US (zones 5-7), first fall frost typically arrives between late September and early November [3]. Knowing your local frost date determines when you need to start taking action.

Picking Varieties That Actually Work in Fall

Not all tomatoes are created equal when temperatures start dropping. The variety you planted back in May makes a huge difference when you’re trying to squeeze out a few more weeks.

Determinate varieties have a big advantage for fall because they produce their entire crop within a concentrated window – usually four to six weeks [4]. When frost is coming, you want tomatoes that are already sizing up and starting to ripen, not plants still trying to make new flowers. Iowa State University Extension specifically recommends determinates for short-season areas because they mature their whole crop before cold weather arrives [4].

That said, indeterminate varieties can provide more quality late-season fruit if you manage them right, according to Cornell research [5]. They keep producing continuously until frost kills them. The trick is topping them about a month before your expected frost date to redirect energy into ripening existing fruit rather than making new growth.

Some varieties consistently perform better in cool weather:

Oregon Spring (58-60 days) was bred specifically for the Pacific Northwest’s cool, cloudy summers and is nearly seedless [6]. It’s one of those varieties that actually sets fruit in conditions that would shut down most tomatoes.

Stupice, a Czech heirloom, has proven itself over and over in cool temperatures. UC Agriculture and Natural Resources gives it high marks for both performance and flavor [7]. Days to maturity: 52-60.

Early Girl remains solid at 50-62 days. Not the earliest thing ever despite the name, but it’s reliable and produces decent-sized fruit quickly [4].

For something truly cold-tolerant, check out Siberian-type tomatoes. Siberian itself can reportedly set fruit at temperatures as low as 38°F, according to databases citing research from the Siberian Institute of Horticulture [8]. Sub Arctic Plenty, developed at Canada’s Beaverlodge Research Station, matures in as few as 42 days [9].

These aren’t gonna win any flavor contests against heirloom beefsteaks. But they’ll produce when nothing else will.

Oregon State University has also developed parthenocarpic varieties – tomatoes that set fruit without normal pollination. Legend, Siletz, and Santiam will keep producing even when temperatures drop too low for normal fruit set [6]. Pretty cool adaptation.

Frost Protection That Actually Works

Row Covers

Floating row covers are the easiest solution. New Mexico State testing found lightweight covers (0.45-0.5 oz per square yard) provide about 2°F protection, while heavyweight versions (1.5-2.2 oz per square yard) add 6-10°F [10].

Here’s something cool: row covers work BETTER in fall than spring [10]. Why? The soil stored heat all summer and keeps releasing it at night. This thermal mass effect is on your side.

Drape fabric over plants or support with hoops. Secure edges with rocks or stakes. Leave lightweight covers on for extended periods, but remove heavy ones on warm days above 60°F.

Cold Frames and Water Protection

Cold frames with plastic covers provide 3-6°F protection [11]. Add old-fashioned Christmas lights (not LEDs – you need the heat) and gain another 6-18°F. Colorado State tested this combo and prevented freezing when outside temps hit 0°F [11].

Wall O’ Water devices work because water releases heat as it freezes [11]. Virginia Tech found they retained night temps 3.4°F warmer and ripened fruit 11 days earlier than uncovered plants [12].

What Doesn’t Work

Old bedsheets? Maybe save you from super light frost (32-34°F) but that’s it. Plastic directly on plants is terrible – it’ll freeze-burn any foliage it touches. Just watering heavily? Not reliable enough by itself.

Getting Green Tomatoes to Ripen Indoors

When frost finally threatens and you’ve got plants full of green tomatoes, don’t panic and don’t toss them. Tomatoes are climacteric fruits, meaning they continue ripening after harvest thanks to ethylene gas production [13].

The magic stage is “breaker” – when 10-30% of the tomato’s surface shows pink or red coloration at the blossom end [14]. At this point, the tomato is producing ethylene internally and has all the sugars and compounds needed to develop full flavor. Texas A&M AgriLife Extension actually considers breaker-stage tomatoes “vine-ripened” by horticultural standards [15].

Mature green tomatoes will also ripen, but you need to know what you’re looking for. According to University of Alaska Fairbanks, mature green tomatoes have:

• Cream-colored streaks visible at the blossom end
• Skin that’s tough and not easily broken when scraped with a thumbnail
• Pulp surrounding the seeds that has become jellylike [16]

If you slice one open and the seeds slip aside rather than being easily cut, you’ve got a mature green tomato that will ripen successfully.

Immature tomatoes will either fail to ripen or produce something tough, poorly colored, and disappointing. Colorado State warns that immature green fruit is more likely to spoil than ripen [17].

Storage Conditions

Once harvested, store your green tomatoes at 65-70°F for optimal ripening – they should turn red in about two weeks at this temperature [17]. Keep humidity around 85-90% to prevent shriveling [16].

Light isn’t necessary and actually shortens shelf life. South Dakota State University specifically warns against sunny windowsills [18]. A dark closet or basement shelf works perfectly.

To speed things up, add a ripe banana or apple to the container – these fruits produce ethylene gas that accelerates ripening [19]. Or add one or two already-ripe tomatoes to a box of green ones.

One old-timer trick that actually has scientific backing: pull the entire plant by its roots before frost and hang it upside down in a garage or basement [16]. The fruit will continue ripening over an extended period, giving you a staggered harvest. Just make sure temperatures stay above 50°F.

Late-Season Pruning and Care

Top indeterminate plants one month before expected frost by removing the top 4 inches of the main stem [20]. This channels sugars into ripening existing fruit. Remove remaining flowers and small fruit that won’t mature.

Don’t remove healthy leaves. Cornell points out that light has little to do with ripening, and fruit exposed to direct sun may overheat and inhibit pigment development [21]. Remove diseased leaves, leave healthy ones.

Stop fertilizing 4-6 weeks before frost. Plants ripen fruit faster without fertilizer [22]. Excess nitrogen creates unnecessary growth and delays ripening. If anything, focus on potassium – it’s critical for color development [23].

Reduce watering as temps cool but keep it consistent. Main concern is splitting from rapid water uptake after dry periods [24].

Fall Disease Concerns

Cooler, wetter fall weather creates ideal conditions for diseases that thrive when summer’s heat fades.

Late blight favors temperatures between 50-70°F combined with high humidity, rain, fog, or heavy dew [25] – exactly what many gardeners experience in September and October.

Unlike early blight which starts on lower leaves, late blight infections move from outside of the plant canopy inward and can appear anywhere. Under favorable conditions, lesions may appear within three to five days of infection [25]. If late blight is reported in your area, begin fungicide applications preventatively.

Septoria leaf spot and early blight also become more problematic in fall’s wet conditions. Both cause rapid defoliation if left untreated [26].

Your best prevention strategies:

• Water in the morning so leaves dry quickly
• Use drip irrigation rather than overhead watering
• Maintain good air circulation through proper spacing
• Apply 2-4 inches of organic mulch to act as a barrier against fungal spores splashing up from soil [27]

At season’s end, remove all tomato plant debris from the garden and till thoroughly. This breaks up infected material and reduces overwintering of pathogens and pests [27]. Rotate your tomatoes to a new location next year – no tomatoes, potatoes, peppers, or eggplants should have grown in that spot for three to four years.

Calculating Your Fall Planting Window

If you want tomatoes that are actively ripening as fall begins – rather than desperately trying to save green fruit from frost – consider a second summer planting specifically for fall harvest.

The basic formula from Texas A&M AgriLife Extension: transplant fall tomatoes approximately 100 days before your expected first frost [28].

For a Zone 6 garden with an October 15 frost date, working backward: subtract 100 days and you get a latest transplant date around July 7-15. Choose an early-maturing variety (60-70 days) rather than a slow beefsteak type.

Oregon State Extension recommends adding 10-14 days to any days-to-maturity figure when growing in cooler conditions, since reduced temperatures slow plant development [6].

In southern regions with later frost dates, Mississippi State Extension notes that transplants can go in from July through early August for harvests extending into October or November [29]. Texas gardeners may wait until late August or early September, avoiding harsh summer heat entirely and producing until the first winter freeze.

The fall tomato crop often produces exceptional fruit because plants aren’t stressed by midsummer heat. Those 85-90°F August days that caused blossom drop and poor fruit set? Your fall plants will be setting fruit when temperatures are much more favorable.

What Actually Matters Most

After growing tomatoes through multiple fall seasons, here’s what really makes the difference:

1. Know your temperatures

• Start thinking about fall protection when nighttime temps consistently hit 50-55°F
• Have frost protection ready when temps are forecast below 40°F
• Harvest all fruit before hard freeze (28°F or below)

2. Choose appropriate varieties

• Early-maturing types for late plantings
• Cold-tolerant varieties if your falls are reliably cool
• Determinates if you have a short window

3. Adjust care in late season

• Stop fertilizing 4-6 weeks before frost
• Reduce watering as temps cool
• Prune off flowers and tiny fruit that won’t mature

4. Use proper frost protection

• Row covers for light frost (32-36°F)
• Cold frames or more elaborate protection for harder freezes
• Remove protection during warm days

5. Harvest strategically

• Pick breaker-stage fruit for best indoor ripening
• Mature green tomatoes will ripen; immature won’t
• Store at 65-70°F in the dark

The research backs up what experienced gardeners figured out through trial and error. It’s not magic, just understanding plant biology and working with it instead of against it.

Start planning your fall tomato strategy in late summer, not when frost is in the forecast. Make incremental adjustments to care as temperatures cool. Use protection methods that actually have evidence behind them. And be realistic about what’s possible in your climate.

Some years you’ll be harvesting tomatoes into November. Other years early cold will end things in September. That’s gardening. But these techniques will consistently add weeks to your season and save fruit that would otherwise be lost.

---

Sources

[1] Cornell Cooperative Extension, Cornell Vegetable Program, “Why Aren’t My Tomatoes Ripening?” https://cvp.cce.cornell.edu/submission.php?id=91

[2] University of California Davis, Postharvest Research and Extension Center, “Tomato” https://postharvest.ucdavis.edu/produce-facts-sheets/tomato

[3] USDA Plant Hardiness Zone Map, https://planthardiness.ars.usda.gov/; Old Farmer’s Almanac Frost Dates, https://www.almanac.com/gardening/frostdates

[4] Iowa State University Extension, “Growing Tomatoes in the Home Garden” https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/

[5] Cornell University Extension, “Determinate vs Indeterminate Tomatoes” https://hort.cornell.edu/

[6] Oregon State University Extension, EC 1333: “Grow Your Own Tomatoes and Tomatillos” https://extension.oregonstate.edu/

[7] UC Agriculture and Natural Resources, “Tomato Variety Information” https://ucanr.edu/

[8] Specialty Produce Database, “Siberian Heirloom Tomatoes” https://specialtyproduce.com/produce/Siberian_Heirloom_Tomatoes_12690.php

[9] Ecoseedbank Canada, “Sub Arctic Plenty” https://ecoseedbank.com/

[10] New Mexico State University Extension, H-251: “Row Covers for Garden Plants” https://pubs.nmsu.edu/

[11] Colorado State University Extension, GardenNotes #722: “Season Extension Techniques for Home Gardeners” https://cmg.extension.colostate.edu/

[12] Cornell University, “Protecting Plants for Earlier Plantings” https://cals.cornell.edu/

[13] University of Maryland Extension, “Ethylene and the Regulation of Fruit Ripening” https://extension.umd.edu/

[14] Penn State Extension, “Is This Tomato Ready to Harvest?” https://extension.psu.edu/

[15] Texas A&M AgriLife Extension, “Pick Tomatoes at Color Break Stage” https://agrilifetoday.tamu.edu/

[16] University of Alaska Fairbanks Cooperative Extension, “A Harvest of Green Tomatoes” https://www.uaf.edu/ces/publications/database/food/green-tomatoes.php

[17] Colorado State University Extension, “Ripening Tomatoes Indoors” https://extension.colostate.edu/; PlantTalk #1844 https://planttalk.colostate.edu/

[18] South Dakota State University Extension, “Will Heat Make My Tomatoes Ripen Faster?” https://extension.sdstate.edu/will-heat-make-my-tomatoes-ripen-faster

[19] UC Agriculture and Natural Resources, “Ripening Fruit” https://ucanr.edu/

[20] Ohio State University Extension, HYG-1624: “Growing Tomatoes in the Home Garden” https://ohioline.osu.edu/factsheet/HYG-1624

[21] Cornell Vegetable Program, “Why Aren’t My Tomatoes Ripening?” https://cvp.cce.cornell.edu/submission.php?id=91

[22] Oregon State University Extension, “Tomato Culture” https://extension.oregonstate.edu/

[23] University of Maryland Extension, “Tomato Ripening Problems and the Role of Potassium” https://extension.umd.edu/

[24] Iowa State University Extension, “Why Are My Tomatoes Cracking?” https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/

[25] University of Florida EDIS, “Late Blight of Tomato” https://edis.ifas.ufl.edu/; NC State Extension, “Tomato Late Blight” https://content.ces.ncsu.edu/

[26] West Virginia University Extension, “Septoria Leaf Spot of Tomato” https://extension.wvu.edu/

[27] Iowa State University Extension, “Managing Tomato Diseases, Disorders, and Pests in the Home Garden” https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/

[28] Texas A&M AgriLife Extension, “Fall Tomatoes” https://tamu.edu/

[29] Mississippi State University Extension, “Growing Fall Tomatoes” https://extension.msstate.edu/